This recipe for Spiedini alla Siciliana or Sicilian Spiedini is an old family recipes that is great for parties and always a crowd pleaser! This is the recipe I made on the Today Show!
I’ll never forget the first time I sat down at an Italian restaurant and saw “spiedini” written on the menu. My eyes widened as I remembered one of my favorite childhood dinners: thin slices of breaded meat wrapped around a filling of tomato, onion, breadcrumbs and cheese. My family called them spiedini and we ate them on a fairly regular basis. It had been ages since I’d even heard the word spiedini, let alone eaten them, and I always chalked them up to being the same as bysta sugu: a food that only people in my family have ever heard of.
But after I read the description, I realized what was being offered here wasn’t even remotely close to the spiedini I grew up eating. We ordered it anyway. It was a long skewer with juicy grilled chunks of swordfish, and it was delicious.
But it wasn’t spiedini. At least not in my eyes.
Turns out, “spiedini” translates to “skewers” in Italian and can refer to just about any food thats been cooked on a stick. Shish kebab? In Italy that’s called spiedini. Chicken satay? Spiedini. A corndog? Spiedini. It’s all spiedini.
But what about the spiedini I grew up with? Surely they have to be a thing somewhere other than my childhood home.
They are. These spiedini are known as Spiedini alla Siciliana; a Sicilian dish popular in my mom’s birth town of Gloucester, Massachusetts. Very different from the more common Spiedini ala Romana, which are skewers of fried bread, cheese and anchovy.
I started to crave spiedini. My spiedini. It had been so long since I’d tasted them, and I was starting to wonder if they really were as good as I remembered. Maybe it was just the memories that I missed and the nostalgia I craved. It was time to find out.
I went to two different sources for a recipe, and since they differed a bit, I had to make them both ways to see which I preferred. The first person I sought out was Mary Ann Genovese, a Sicilian-American Gloucester native who’s married to my Mom’s cousin Paul. She’s an enthusiastic cook who’s become known in our extended family for her spiedini. She sent me her recipe, and after looking it over, I noticed some things were different than what I remembered. Since Mary Ann isn’t a blood relative, it made sense that her recipe would differ a bit. So I called my Aunt Angela, my mom’s younger sister, to find out how she makes hers.
Here’s the lowdown:
Both consisted of the same basic ingredients: thin slices of top round beef (called “skinny meat” in our house) that have been lightly breaded and stuffed with a mixture of Italian seasoned breadcrumbs, tomato sauce, chopped onions, and pecorino Romano cheese.
Mary Ann’s version uses a thin slice Genoa salami in addition to the other ingredients, sautés sliced onions, and tucks bay leaves between the bundles as they bake (an old trick she learned from her Nonna).
Ang’s version, which is exactly like I remember, has no salami, uses raw minced onions and no bay leaves while baking (although we always use bay in our sauce).
The biggest difference really lies in how they’re assembled: the version I remember from my childhood had you put a dollop of filling- cheese and all- in the center of the meat, then bunch it up with your hands and secure the top with two criss-crossing toothpicks. I’m guessing this is how they got the name spiedini.
Mary Ann’s recipe has you place a slice of salami on the meat, then a dollop of the filling (breadcrumbs, onions and sauce only) on the edge, then a matchstick of cheese, then roll them up like a cigar. I suppose you could use a toothpick to secure the rolls, but it’s really not necessary. This technique reminded me of how I make braciole.
The verdict? After making and taste testing both versions side by side, Chaser and I found that, well, they’re both good. Like, really good.
Ang’s recipe was exactly as I remembered. Chaser and I both liked that the little bundles held a bit more filling than the rolled version. We’re filling people. But on the downside, they were much more labor intensive, taking a bit more time to bunch up and skewer each one.
Mary Ann’s were much easier to assemble and had slightly less filling, but were still just as tasty. I wasn’t sure if I was going to like the addition of salami, but I did. I liked it a lot. It added a salty, slightly funky note that was barely discernible, but there. The bay leaves added the most beautiful perfume during cooking, but this came as no surprise since I adore the flavor of bay (bae!) in anything. I’ll definitely be making my spiedini with salami and bay forever and ever until the end of time.
Everyone wins! High fives all around!
As for the onions: to sauté or not to sauté? I say skip it. I thought using raw onions might be a little too harsh, but if minced finely, after baking in the oven they mellow out just enough. Plus, I actually like the little bit of bite they have left, it adds a nice textural contrast to the overall dish. The sautéed onions were totally fine too, but if I can get by without having to dirty another pan, I’m gonna go for it.
After making them this week, Chaser asked me why I’d been holding out on him all these years. I’m not really sure why I waited so long to make these, but they will now find themselves in our regular menu rotation. They’re just so uniquely delicious.
Below is my own recipe for Spiedini alla Siciliana, a combination of my family’s recipe and Mary Ann’s Sanfilippo family recipe. The best of both worlds. I hope you enjoy them as much as we do.
- 1 lb beef cutlets, very thinly sliced and pounded out (if needed) to be about 1/8-1/4 inch thick *
- 1/4 cup olive or vegetable oil, or more as needed
- 3 cups Italian seasoned breadcrumbs, or more as needed
- 2 cups tomato sauce, any kind, though homemade is preferred
- 1 large yellow onion, finely minced
- 4 oz pecorino Romano cheese, cut into small chunks
- 20 slices Genoa salami, very thinly sliced (about 1 slice per cutlet), optional
- Toothpicks, optional
- Dried bay leaves, optional
- Arrange a work space by filling a medium, shallow bowl with oil and filling another medium, shallow bowl with about 2 cups of breadcrumbs. Working one at a time, dip each cutlet in oil, allowing the excess to drip off, and then dredge in breadcrumbs. Set aside.
- Mix together the tomato sauce, onions and cheese, then add a few handfuls of seasoned breadcrumbs a little at a time until the mixture is the consistency of runny oatmeal - but not too wet. If it’s too saucy it will ooze out when you roll these up.
- Create an assembly line by placing a stack of breaded cutlets next to a stack of sliced salami (if using), and the bowl of filling. Place a few cutlets down on a cutting board, then lay a piece or two of salami (if using) on top. Place a heaping teaspoon of filling on top of the salami, being careful not to put too much. At this point, you can choose to roll them up like cigars or bunch the meat up into a pouch and use two toothpicks to hold it closed.
- Place the spiedini into a greased baking dish. Be sure to pack them in tight, as this will help them cook evenly. Preheat the oven to 425 degrees.
- Once all the spiedini are made, spoon any extra sauce, onion, or breadcrumb mixture into any holes in the pan. Use it all up to help keep the spiedini moist, and not to waste any. If you don’t have any mixture left, you can mix together a little sauce and breadcrumbs. No need to chop more onions and cheese for this part if you don’t have any left.
- Break up some pieces of dried bay leaves and tuck them in between each spiedini. This is optional, but gives them a nice, subtle flavor.
- Cover the pan with foil and bake for 15 minutes. Remove the foil and bake for another 10 minutes or so until the breadcrumbs are golden brown. Serve hot or warm.
- * I used eye round cutlets sold as "sandwich steaks" because that’s what they offer in my grocery store, but any cut will work as long as they are nice and thin
- * Mary Ann's rule is that these should be finger food: 2-3 per person as an appetizer or 4-6 per person as an entree
- * Any cutlets that are too large after pounding out can be cut in half
Nicole Gaffney, aka Coley, is a professionally trained chef, recipe developer, tv host and food writer.
Can’t wait to make this. Thanks
omfg my site is 10 years old and this post is longer than all my posts combined. And no, I am not sure if that is a compliment or an insult.
Rating: Long Place!
I was looking up recipes for spiedini since it was such a childhood favorite though I’ve yet to make them. My mom used to buy them at Trupiano’s in Gloucester, yes, gloucester born & still here. That store closed so long ago & trying to find spiedini made the way they made them is near impossible. They made them with the salami & it’s the only way I’ll eat them especially since eating them any other way just doesn’t do it for me. Thanks so much for sharing your families recipes!
I came across your website when trying to determine if bra hole and spiedini were the same thing (I still don’t know). My big, Sicilian, St. Louis family makes spiedini for almost ever occasion (but most certainly for Easter, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day). Our recipe is similar to your Aunt Angela’s. Oh I miss a good spiedini! But your added touch with the salami sounds amazing! Thanks for sharing your recipe. And BTW, I know what bysta sugo is (we pronounce it basta Sugo). Most people I know have no idea what it is either but once they taste it, it’s a meal they never forget!
Hey Christi! Thank you so much for this comment. I’m so excited to hear that your family has so many food similarities to mine! In regard to spiedini vs. braciole, thought hey are very similar, there is definitely a difference. For me anyway, braciole is rolled up, then braised in tomato sauce (usually with wine) until it’s really tender, and then served with the sauce and sometimes pasta. Spiedini on the other hand are breaded and baked,and don’t get served with a sauce other than whats used to moisten the filling. Spiedini can be eaten as finger food, while braciole requires a knife and fork. I see braciole as being a wet dish and spiedini as being a dry dish, if that makes sense, lol.
I married into a Sicilian family in St. Louis and our spiedinis are quite similar excep no onion – just garlic. They are grilled outside which to me is the best way possible! Nothing like them in the article it mentions crunching them together or using toothpicks. We assembled them as you would a diaper and put the seam side down. Never a problem. Bottom piece up over bread crumb mixture-then the two sides flapped in. Gently roll over from bottom.
Do you know off there’s one that’s made where three rolls are put in a pic, then dredged in egg and crumbs and pan fried? The other ingredients sound about right but no tomato sauce, what I remember was more like a finger food… and eaten dry…
I have heard of these but not ever had them before. This is how my family makes them – they are like a finger food too. They sound delicious though!
Came across your page while looking for the spelling of spiedini. I’m making this tonight for my son’s birthday dinner and it has been a family recipe for generations. My family originally hails from Augusta, Sicily and we have been making spiedini as you describe it here for ever *you are not alone* 🙂
ps (we also say “bysta” rather than pasta and “sugo” rather than sauce).
Good work here.
Your story began just like my experience. Eyes wide, so excited someone else, menu also in my case, knew what a Spiedini was. At that restaurant it was fried cheese? Not even on a skewer but still yum anyhow.
My family puts them on skewers and onto the grill/BBQ. They look more like Mary Ann’s. Rolled up with the filling spread thinly across the whole slice and quarters of onion and bay leaves are alternated between the meat. But man adding salami and a matchstick of cheese sounds amazing! And baking them would be awesome in winter. These are generally made for Easter and Christmas in my family. Love, Love Spiedini!
I loved receiving this comment! It’s been so interesting to learn about the different interpretations of this dish. I’m curious where you’re from? Someone from New York e-mailed me his family’s recipe and it sounds like yours. I want to try that version next! I hope you love my recipe. 🙂
Can these be frozen either cooked or uncooked
Thanks for this recipe
I had something like this about 40years ago and have wanted to try to make them since then but never found a good recipe
Hmm.. I’ve never tried freezing them, but I imagine they’d hold up alright. I’d probably cook them first and the freeze, and just reheat in the oven. If you try it, let me know how they turn out!
In my family spedini are mini personalized braciole and neither of them equal heaven to me if they do not have the boiled egg. In spiedini the egg is diced and placed inside the rolled toothpicked meat along with diced cheese, salami (or no salami) and ofcourse breadcrumbs.
We also cook our spiedini in sauce, I have had as you put it the “dry” version and really prefer it cooked in the sauce; it just melts in the mouth. Thank you for sharing your recipe – I always love to find other people’s recipes because it may inspire me to add something new to a dish I adore.
Thank you so much for your comment!! I love hearing about all the different variations of Spiedini out there. Just curious, where are you from??
My grandfather grandpa’s parents came to the US from Palermo they made a life in Milwaukee Wisconsin which honestly has a very dense and large population
of Italian/Sicilian Americans. I grew up going to a deli that imported so many cheeses, salamis, meets canned goods and etc. Kiddy corner from the deli is the most delicious and divine bakery filled with only Italian sweets. Milwaukee is pretty awesome because as soon as summer comes we have ethnic festivals that are held on the grounds of the largest music festival in the world summerfest. Ofcourse my favorite has always been
festaitaliana.com
It pulls in the most people at roughly double the amount of attendees to Milwaukee’s other ethnic festivals. In fact my son was even able to join the childrens Italian dance group because funds are provided thru the Italian community center to make sure the next generationsare able to not only learn about the Italian culture but also participate in the culture.
🙂
Thanks for the background, I love it! I also had no idea there was such a big Italian/Sicilian presence in Milwaukee. It sounds like I need to take a little trip this summer! 🙂
My grandfather taught me how to make these. He was from Lercara Friddi, Palermo. We made this dish on special Holidays and it has always been my favorite. We use thin sliced veal, and for filling: breadcrumbs mixed with Romano grated cheese, garlic powder, and parsley. Each slice has a small piece of bacon and tab of butter. Roll and skewer 3 pieces together with toothpicks. If I have any leftover filling, I sprinkle on top of spiedini (I always spelled it spattini). I enjoyed reading all the variations.
So interesting to see all the variations. My mother and father-in-law were both from Palazzo Adriano in Sicily. Their spiedinis were a bit different from the last post that I read, using tomatoes breadcrumbs, garlic and Romano cheese. We also used veal when it wasn’t too expensive and the rest of the time beef! We also had them for special holidays.
Try prosciutto instead of salami, more expensive but I believe you’ll like it better.
oh, yum! I like anything with prosciutto, so you’re probably right! Thanks for the tip, I’m going to try it next time I make them.
I am so excited to have stumbled across your recipe and the essay accompanying it that I have forgotten what I was doing that landed me here!
Spiedini was a very special Sunday meal when I was growing up. My mother’s parents were both from Sciacca, Sicily. They met and married here so Gtandma’s and Mom’s cooking was a real mix of Italian, Sicilian, American. I could never figure out what came from where or where to find recipes or even what they would be called by others.
Fortunately my Mom is still around although, at 97, her memory isn’t always as sharp as it was. But she can still often point me in the right direction to find details for some of my sketchy memories. This particular dish is one we both remember but one I never tried to recreate.
Until recently I was working full time while taking care of Mom by myself and spiedini was a meal that was too labor intensive to try. Our version is made with veal pounded very thin. The filling is mostly seasoned breadcrumbs browned in butter and they are rolled then sealed with a toothpick.
A major reason I never tried to make them is that I never knew they could be baked. Growing up we always had a big precursor to the toaster oven. It broiled, roasted, baked, and had a self-rotating spit. That’s what we used for the spiedini. My brother and I used to stand there and watch the tine spiedini rolls turning on the spit and listen to the sizzle of the juices.
When the old broiler/spit went away, we never had spiedini again. Now I’m so excited to try the baking method. Thank you for giving us back a sepcial memory. I’ll definitely be back to visit your site.
Thanks for leaving such an awesome comment! I loved reading this. What an amazing memory. I hope you try my family’s version of spiedini and let me know what you think! <3
I used to help my mom make these as a kid in the 1970,s.. we used bacon.. and I remember using dollops of crisco on the baking sheet.
I think we cooked them in wine as well..